Categories
Uncategorized

Maybe we all judged Merrick Garland a bit too harshly, filing against Trump’s Executive Privilege nonsense pulls no punches

(A previous version of this story had the wrong document number and referred to an earlier document submitted in this case. This story has been corrected to reflect statements from Document #21, which was filed by the Department of Justice on October 30th.)

We’re all frustrated with the slow pace of the January 6th investigation. We’re down to just a year before the next election and it feels like things are dragging on endlessly and Democrats just don’t have any sense of urgency to get things taken care of in the little bit of time that’s left. Fortunately, there is hope, A new filing in the case that the forrmer guy filed to try to block sharing of White House records shows a Congress that is ready to come out swinging. Here are several highlights from the filing.

(Legal citations have been omitted to make for easier reading, though the full citations from the conclusion of the document may be found at the link above, from 35 on)

“President Biden’s decision in this extraordinary case does not diminish the well-established importance of protecting presidential communications, see United States v. Nixon, supra, nor diminish the force of constitutionally-based privileges in the ordinary case.”

“Plaintiff claims that failing to assert executive privilege “is attempting to damage Democracy itself.”…But it was the actual attack on democracy that occurred on January 6, the potential involvement of high-ranking federal officials in activities related to that event, and the public’s interest in preventing such an attack in the future, that prompted President Biden to provide even privileged information to Congress in aid of its inquiry. The incumbent President has determined that the need for Congress to develop a complete understanding of what happened on January 6 outweighs the interest in confidentiality that might ordinarily attach to documents containing presidential communications.”

“[E]xecutive privilege principally exists to protect Executive Branch interests, and the incumbent President is charged with protecting those interests…And President Biden’s determination not to uphold privilege here was supported by an extraordinarily compelling rationale—i.e., the “unique and extraordinary circumstances” surrounding the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol.”

“Plaintiff’s claim is also unsustainable because it is based on a misunderstanding of the [Presidential Records Act]. The PRA does not create or expand executive privilege authority; rather, executive privilege arises from the Constitution, Nixon v. GSA, 433 U.S. at 447, and the Constitution assigns greater weight to the incumbent’s privilege determination because the incumbent is “in the best position to assess the present and future needs of the Executive branch.”

“Plaintiff Meets None of the Equitable Requirements for Preliminary Injunctive Relief. In addition to the fact that former President Trump’s claims exhibit no likelihood of success, his request for preliminary relief halting all compliance with the Select Committee’s request must be denied, as he has satisfied none of the equitable pre-requisites for such sweeping relief.”

“Plaintiff’s request for preliminary relief must also be denied because he has not shown that the balance of equities tips in his favor, or that injunctive relief would serve the public interest. It should require no further explanation that discovering and coming to terms with the causes underlying the January 6 attack is a matter of unsurpassed public importance.”

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

Eric Trump-backed killer robot startup founder’s embezzlement raises questions over Trump Admin’s ability to unleash AI uprising

17 hours ago

Sean Duffy refuses to apologize for Pete Buttigieg’s atrocities

18 hours ago

Flight safety expert weighs in on air traffic modernization efforts

19 hours ago

“They thought the ad was in poor taste, but…”

1 day ago

Buttigiegment Day

2 days ago

Team Orange pushes back Medicaid work requirements

2 days ago

Regime allowed illegal Chinese vapes imported to benefit crony

2 days ago

Markwayne turns all woke speech-police on reporter

2 days ago

FAA orders nationwide ground halt

3 days ago

“Front Row Joe” says he voted for Amy Acton and Sherrod Brown

3 days ago

Jaydee leaning toward sitting out 2028: CNN

3 days ago

Scott Bessent throws Howard Nutlick to the wolves

3 days ago

Final weeks before election saw massive pro-Dem sandbagging

3 days ago

An economy depending on one guy to not fuck around is…

3 days ago

Todd not sure how to answer question on nonexistent voter fraud

4 days ago

Trump appoints Tim Apple to run Nvidia

4 days ago

Nvidia CEO resigns

4 days ago

Caravan scam continues apace

4 days ago

CNN calls Mississippi for Scott Colom

4 days ago

Ilhan Omar’s bodyguard indicted to try to get him to “flip”: NYT

5 days ago

Insufferable shithead MAGA Congressman Greg Murphy concedes

5 days ago

“We did do a very poor job”

5 days ago

Regime sends letter warning Garcia of “criminal consequences”

5 days ago

Mary Peltola’s vote total now larger than both Dan Sullivans

5 days ago

Hegseth COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY EXONERATED

5 days ago

Tom Emmer promises Dems will regret winning

6 days ago

Jim Jordan wins House GOP leadership, lol

6 days ago

“Many Democrat lawmakers are going to find themselves under indictment and fighting conviction… Watch”: Roger Stone to Axios

6 days ago

Bidenflation increases 0.4 percent in October, beating expectations

6 days ago

WATCH LIVE: Petey Pee Pants calls impeachment gay and soy

6 days ago

Orange Baby still demanding Dan Sullivan be declared winner

6 days ago

Orange God Emperor holds impromptu press briefing: Watch live

7 days ago

“Voters made the wrong choice”

7 days ago

Massie intros Hegseth impeachment articles

7 days ago

Nvidia CEO hired top sex scandal specialist PR firm a year ago

7 days ago

There it is: Trump “Stop the Steal 2026” edition

7 days ago

Russell Brand gets 10.5 years in the joint following rape conviction

7 days ago

Jaydee “blamed the Jews for losing the election”: Randy Fine

7 days ago

Jensen Huang in better shape with Trump than JD Vance

1 week ago

Katie Miller cancels podcast

1 week ago

Todd says he’s investigating Dem “threats”: Sunday Live updates

1 week ago

Mentally ill senior having fun Saturday shitposting on internet

1 week ago

Will Dems even need to nuke the filibuster in 2029?

1 week ago

Top Trump crony Huang targeted by sexy Chicom intel agent

1 week ago

WATCH LIVE: Trump complains about losing to NASA

1 week ago

Wiles fired, Stephen Miller promoted to White House Chief of Staff

1 week ago

RNC chair, who just oversaw worst loss in decades, endorsed

1 week ago

“Grand Conspiracy” case’s lead prosecutor resigns

1 week ago

Cybertruck era ends with such poetic timing

1 week ago

President mentally incapable of serving: Fox News exit poll majority

1 week ago

x
x
x
x
x
x