Categories
Uncategorized

Rand Paul says lower death rate for coronavirus in Asia due to population’s more frequent exposure to cold viruses

Kentucky republican Senator Rand Paul, a self-described doctor who formed a professional board for ophthalmologists so he could keep his certification, questioned Dr. Anthony Fauci about the effectiveness of lockdowns in controlling the coronavirus, citing Sweden as an example of effective “herd immunity” practice.

Dr. Fauci, however, spoke quickly and authoritatively to shut down Paul’s misleading arguments and misrepresentation of facts, saying he wasn’t listening to the facts being presented.

Repeatedly using the “some would argue…” fallacy to gloss over examples that defeat his point, Paul claimed that regardless of social distancing and lock-down orders, the virus would spread and “flattening the curve” would still result in the same amount of fatalities.

Paul asked Dr. Anthony Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, “Is man really capable of altering the course of an infectious disease through crowd control?”

Paul argued that lower death rates in Asia was not due to lockdown and isolation practices, but “One explanation for the low death rate in much of Asia is that population may have a higher degree of exposure to coronavirus colds and therefore have more preexisting cross-reactive immunity.”

You read the right:  Paul said Asia has a lower coronavirus fatality rate because Asian people might get colds more.

Paul’s unfactual screed came down to promoting his libertarian beliefs:  “While there are still many things we need to learn about this pandemic, it’s important that we the people simply not acquiesce to the authoritarian mandates on our behavior without first making the ‘nanny state’ prove their hypothesis.”

Paul asked Dr. Fauci if he had any “second thoughts” on his mitigation recommendations which led to governors imposing lockdowns.  Dr. Fauci offered to sit down with Paul and educate him on the error of his so-called logic, pointing out that Sweden’s death rate is worse than other Scandinavian countries.

“I don’t think it’s appropriate to compare Sweden with us,” Fauci declared.  “I don’t regret saying that the only way we could’ve stopped the explosion of infection was by essentially–I want to say ‘shutting down’–I mean to say having the physical separation and the kinds of recommendations that we’ve made.”

Paul rebutted that Dr. Fauci praises the actions of New York Governor Andrew Cuomo although, Paul said breathlessly, “New York had the highest death rate in the world!”

“No, you misconstrue that, Senator,” Dr. Fauci shot back, “and you done that repetitively in the past.”

Dr. Fauci noted that “New York got hit very badly.  They made some mistakes,” but that New York State has largely been following the CDC guidelines, which has led to a test positivity rate of 1% or less.

Paul interrupted, “OR they developed enough community immunity that they’re no longer having the pandemic because they have enough immunity in New York City to actually stop it.”

Again, Dr. Fauci forcefully responded:  “I challenge, Senator.”  After being told Paul’s time had expired, Fauci insisted on responding saying, “Please, sir, I would like to respond because this happens with Senator Rand [sic] all the time.”

Dr. Fauci continued.  “You were not listening to what the director of the CDC said, that in New York it’s about 22%.  If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that.”

Paul reiterated his point that the common cold provides immunity, to which Dr. Fauci noted a recent study that shows there’s no cross-reaction between the common cold and COVID-19.

The main fallacy of Paul’s argument, however, is the idea of flattening the curve is to avoid a spike in fatalities and infections for two reasons:  first, to prevent medical systems from getting overwhelmed, which would result in more deaths; and second, to delay infections to allow scientists to design treatments and vaccines that would prevent deaths.

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

Regime drops Alaska lawsuit Senate due to Peltola’s margins

1 hour ago

Fiona the Hippo has died from eating a hat

4 hours ago

Vice pays up to virtue in shrill Fox News bit on Grand Theft Auto VI

7 hours ago

Man whose friend publicly called him a child rapist last year confused about why friend now falsely claims to not be very MAGA

8 hours ago

Los Angeles MAGA prosecutor assigned to “Grand conspiracy”

10 hours ago

Orange Invalid changes the subject to other failure

12 hours ago

US reporters’ phones confiscated after dictator bro-out: Fox News

15 hours ago

Republicans slide toward long lockout with nothing to show for it

16 hours ago

Frau Ingraham evidently brushing up ahead of move to Argentia

1 day ago

Jaydee cancels NYT summit appearance… minutes beforehand

2 days ago

Garcia responds to Team Orange’s threats with pre-subpoenas

2 days ago

Fox News still butthurt over the “Decoy Dan” thing

2 days ago

They lowered gas prices after the “election”: President

2 days ago

“We still gotta live our life at the same time”

2 days ago

NSA’s internal network crashes

2 days ago

Markwayne flew to Texas-LSU game while FAA chaos still raged

3 days ago

WATCH LIVE: Embarrassment takes stage in Philippines

3 days ago

Iranians trying to detonate dirty bomb in DC: CNN

3 days ago

United Airlines bricked

3 days ago

Widespread bank account access outages reported

3 days ago

Semi-embalmed corpse can’t even get his confused lies straight

3 days ago

True ruler of CBS puts Bari Weiss on notice

4 days ago

Eric Trump-backed killer robot startup founder’s embezzlement raises questions over Trump Admin’s ability to unleash AI uprising

4 days ago

Sean Duffy refuses to apologize for Pete Buttigieg’s atrocities

4 days ago

Flight safety expert weighs in on air traffic modernization efforts

5 days ago

“They thought the ad was in poor taste, but…”

5 days ago

Buttigiegment Day

5 days ago

Team Orange pushes back Medicaid work requirements

5 days ago

Regime allowed illegal Chinese vapes imported to benefit crony

6 days ago

Markwayne turns all woke speech-police on reporter

6 days ago

FAA orders nationwide ground halt

6 days ago

“Front Row Joe” says he voted for Amy Acton and Sherrod Brown

6 days ago

Jaydee leaning toward sitting out 2028: CNN

6 days ago

Scott Bessent throws Howard Nutlick to the wolves

7 days ago

Final weeks before election saw massive pro-Dem sandbagging

7 days ago

An economy depending on one guy to not fuck around is…

1 week ago

Todd not sure how to answer question on nonexistent voter fraud

1 week ago

Trump appoints Tim Apple to run Nvidia

1 week ago

Nvidia CEO resigns

1 week ago

Caravan scam continues apace

1 week ago

CNN calls Mississippi for Scott Colom

1 week ago

Ilhan Omar’s bodyguard indicted to try to get him to “flip”: NYT

1 week ago

Insufferable shithead MAGA Congressman Greg Murphy concedes

1 week ago

“We did do a very poor job”

1 week ago

Regime sends letter warning Garcia of “criminal consequences”

1 week ago

Mary Peltola’s vote total now larger than both Dan Sullivans

1 week ago

Hegseth COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY EXONERATED

1 week ago

Tom Emmer promises Dems will regret winning

1 week ago

Jim Jordan wins House GOP leadership, lol

1 week ago

“Many Democrat lawmakers are going to find themselves under indictment and fighting conviction… Watch”: Roger Stone to Axios

1 week ago

x
x
x
x
x
x