Categories
Uncategorized

Jack Smith tears into Judge Cannon’s request for jury instructions in Florida docs case: “That legal premise is wrong”

Special Counsel Jack Smith’s reply to Judge Aileen Cannon’s request for jury instructions starts with a strong rebuke of the judge’s order, stating the premise of the argument set forth is wrong:

The Court has issued an order (ECF No. 407) directing the parties to file preliminary proposed jury instructions and verdict forms for Counts 1-32 of the Superseding Indictment, with a specific requirement that the parties “engage with [two] competing scenarios and offer alternative draft text that assumes each scenario to be a correct formulation of the law to be issued to the jury.”  Both scenarios rest on an unstated and fundamentally flawed legal premise—namely, that the Presidential Records Act (“PRA”), and in particular its distinction between “personal” and “Presidential” records determines whether a former President is “[]authorized,” under the Espionage Act, 18 U.S.C. § 793(e), to possess highly classified documents and store them in an unsecure facility, despite contrary rules in Executive Order (“EO”) 13526, which governs the possession and storage of classified information.

That legal premise is wrong, and a jury instruction for Section 793 that reflects that premise would distort the trial. The PRA’s distinction between personal and presidential records has no bearing on whether a former President’s possession of documents containing national defense information is authorized under the Espionage Act, and the PRA should play no role in the jury instructions on the elements of Section 793. Indeed, based on the current record, the PRA should not play any role at trial at all.  [Some citations removed.]

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

“You’re supposed to clap!”

7 hours ago

Delaware LLC pays $910,000 extra for Stefanik’s DC home

7 hours ago

Luna fucks off from job due to far-fetched Iranian dirty bomb threat

9 hours ago

WATCH LIVE: Orange Malcontent makes noises to press corps

11 hours ago

Mamdani sidelined with torn achilles

11 hours ago

Most MAGA voters don’t want Congress to investigate Trump: poll

12 hours ago

“The gamer bros are gonna LOVE this!”: Someone’s actual thought

15 hours ago

Regime drops Alaska lawsuit Senate due to Peltola’s margins

1 day ago

Fiona the Hippo has died from eating a hat

1 day ago

Vice pays up to virtue in shrill Fox News bit on Grand Theft Auto VI

1 day ago

Man whose friend publicly called him a child rapist last year confused about why friend now falsely claims to not be very MAGA

1 day ago

Los Angeles MAGA prosecutor assigned to “Grand conspiracy”

1 day ago

Orange Invalid changes the subject to other failure

2 days ago

US reporters’ phones confiscated after dictator bro-out: Fox News

2 days ago

Republicans slide toward long lockout with nothing to show for it

2 days ago

Frau Ingraham evidently brushing up ahead of move to Argentia

2 days ago

Jaydee cancels NYT summit appearance… minutes beforehand

3 days ago

Garcia responds to Team Orange’s threats with pre-subpoenas

3 days ago

Fox News still butthurt over the “Decoy Dan” thing

3 days ago

They lowered gas prices after the “election”: President

3 days ago

“We still gotta live our life at the same time”

3 days ago

NSA’s internal network crashes

4 days ago

Markwayne flew to Texas-LSU game while FAA chaos still raged

4 days ago

WATCH LIVE: Embarrassment takes stage in Philippines

4 days ago

Iranians trying to detonate dirty bomb in DC: CNN

4 days ago

United Airlines bricked

4 days ago

Widespread bank account access outages reported

4 days ago

Semi-embalmed corpse can’t even get his confused lies straight

5 days ago

True ruler of CBS puts Bari Weiss on notice

5 days ago

Eric Trump-backed killer robot startup founder’s embezzlement raises questions over Trump Admin’s ability to unleash AI uprising

5 days ago

Sean Duffy refuses to apologize for Pete Buttigieg’s atrocities

6 days ago

Flight safety expert weighs in on air traffic modernization efforts

6 days ago

“They thought the ad was in poor taste, but…”

6 days ago

Buttigiegment Day

6 days ago

Team Orange pushes back Medicaid work requirements

6 days ago

Regime allowed illegal Chinese vapes imported to benefit crony

7 days ago

Markwayne turns all woke speech-police on reporter

1 week ago

FAA orders nationwide ground halt

1 week ago

“Front Row Joe” says he voted for Amy Acton and Sherrod Brown

1 week ago

Jaydee leaning toward sitting out 2028: CNN

1 week ago

Scott Bessent throws Howard Nutlick to the wolves

1 week ago

Final weeks before election saw massive pro-Dem sandbagging

1 week ago

An economy depending on one guy to not fuck around is…

1 week ago

Todd not sure how to answer question on nonexistent voter fraud

1 week ago

Trump appoints Tim Apple to run Nvidia

1 week ago

Nvidia CEO resigns

1 week ago

Caravan scam continues apace

1 week ago

CNN calls Mississippi for Scott Colom

1 week ago

Ilhan Omar’s bodyguard indicted to try to get him to “flip”: NYT

1 week ago

Insufferable shithead MAGA Congressman Greg Murphy concedes

1 week ago

x
x
x
x
x
x