In a sure sign of desperation over the DOJ investigation of the former guy’s January 6th insurrection attempt at the US Capitol building, TheHill and FOX legal shill Jonathan Turley has published an editorial trying to present a desperate false equivalency between Trump inciting the crowd to violence during his January 6th speech, and Maxine Waters’ statements calling for protesters in Brooklyn Center Minnesota to “stay in the street” and “get confrontational” with police. Turley claims that Waters’ statements could undermine her participation in a lawsuit brought by House Members against the former guy.
In his op-ed Turley states: “Waters insists that Trump telling his supporters to go to the Capitol to make their voice heard and “fight” for their votes was actual criminal incitement. Conversely, Waters was speaking after multiple nights of rioting and looting, telling protesters to stay on the streets and get even more confrontational. Waters has now guaranteed that she could be called as a witness by Trump in his own defense against her own lawsuit.”
Turley’s statements is speculation and projection. The relevant legal standard in this matter comes from the case Brandenburg v. Ohio. In that case the Supreme Court decided that even language calling for violence is protected by the First Amendment, unless it can be shown that language led directly to violent action. The case involved a number of Klan members and basically said that if a group of Klan members are sitting around talking about white supremacy, but they don’t go out and commit acts of violence, then their language is protected speech, but if that group of Klan members gets all worked up and goes out and commits a lynching, then the speech is considered criminal incitement. By that standard Trump’s speech on January 6th was an act of criminal incitement. The “moment of incitement” occurred during the speech when the first wave of insurrectionists left the site of the speech to go to the Capitol building and begin damaging security barricades and attacking Capitol Police Officers. We know that Trump’s words constituted acts of incitement as numerous protesters who have been taken into custody have testified in court that they were there at the behest of President Trump.

