Categories
Uncategorized

Authoritarian GOP state bills designed to prevent people seeking abortions from crossing state lines won’t stand, but will do damage

In their march to shred the Constitution and establish an authoritarian state, Republicans in various state legislatures are proposing bills that would criminalize a pregnant person traveling outside the state to seek an abortion, which these Republicans have made illegal in their states after the jerry-rigged Supreme Court revoke the Roe decision.

Based on two parts of the Constitution–the Privileges and Immunities Clause (Article IV, Section 2, Clause 1) and the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8, Clause 3)–courts have reinforced the right of citizens to travel freely between states for nearly any reason.  Perpetually ignorant of what the Constitution says, Republicans now want to introduce laws upending those rights.

Even the prospect of these laws is ludicrous.  If states could punish people for doing something in another state that was illegal in theirs, Las Vegas would not be.  It would have been illegal to gamble in Sin City and to bring those winnings home.  Going to a dog race in Florida would have landed a Kentuckian in jail.  If an Arizonan were to travel to New Mexico and spit on the sidewalk, he would face a six-month prison sentence upon returning home.  (Yes, according to Arizona state law, it’s illegal to spit in public.)

Do states punish people who partake of things in states they’re visiting that they can’t do back home?  Of course not.  That’s kinda the root of the entire tourism industry, an important part of our national economy responsible for hundreds of billions of dollars in spending, so no state wants to stifle tourism.

A subsegment of tourism, medical tourism, isn’t new either.  I live in Maryland, and thanks to institutions like Johns Hopkins Hospital and the University of Maryland Medical System, people from all over the world come to Baltimore for their medical care.  JHH not only encourages it; they cater to it.  They have facilities for wealthy Middle Eastern patients, with a floor of the hospital looking more like a Ritz Carlton hotel than a traditional recovery ward.

Many of these same states that would punish people for going to another state for abortions are what are known as “right to try” states:  states where patients can access treatments that are not legal in their states because they have not gotten full approval from federal agencies.  These states allow patients with a terminal diagnosis to get drugs that are still in clinical trials even though they are not authorized for general treatment.  Should those patients be punished upon returning home because they got potentially life-saving treatment in another state?  Of course not.

(I am not necessarily a “right to try” advocate.  Too many times, patients and families put so much hope in a miracle drug they believe is available in another state and they abandon traditional life-extending therapies for a long-shot treatment they read about on the internet, doing more harm than good for the patient.  In my opinion, it’s different when a doctor refers you to a therapy versus when someone decides to try it for themselves after reading a story on WebMD.)

Another example of this is a new type of cancer treatment called proton therapy, a process by which a fine stream of protons targets a tumor, destroying it but saving surrounding tissue.  This therapy is available at centers in about 22 states right now.  Should people be punished for seeking proton therapy that is not yet licensed in their states?  Of course not.

The selective enforcement of these laws–only for abortion services and nothing else–demonstrates the contempt Republicans hold for pregnant patients looking to terminate a pregnancy for any reason, even to save their lives or restore a degree of normalcy to a rape victim.

In practice, these laws will be impossible to enforce.  Authoritarian red states would have to require sworn statements from travelers that they are not pregnant when leaving the state, or that they are still pregnant when they return.  They would literally have to set up invasive examination stations to have state-sponsored exams because no doctor can share a patient’s medical information with the government due to HIPAA.

Ultimately, these laws will be ruled unconstitutional on multiple grounds, from the two clauses cited above to HIPAA laws, as will the “snitch” laws put in place by states like Texas and Oklahoma.  But unfortunately, the damage will be done for those patients before the courts can address them.

___________________________________

Side note:  In composing this, I intended to start with the analogy of a boy in 1982 crossing state lines with the intention of avoiding the laws of his state because he could get something legally in the neighboring jurisdiction, and how he went unpunished for it.  But while putting it to paper, I realized the analogy was wrong:  Brett Kavanaugh said he would go to Washington, DC from Maryland in 1982 to drink beer–he really likes beer, in case you hadn’t heard–because 18-year-olds were grandfathered in to the drinking age in DC while the drinking age in Maryland was set at 21, so he would go to DC to do something that was illegal for him in Maryland, and he presumably would return to Maryland in an illegal physical condition:  an underage teenager under the influence of alcohol.

The problem with the analogy is that it still would have been illegal for Kavanaugh to drink beer in DC because he was only 17 in 1982, so Kavanaugh crossed state lines with the intention of breaking the law.  He just went to a place where, with a fake ID, it would have been easier for him to break the law.  (I know how easy it was to do because I did it myself.  I’m not chiding Kavanaugh for doing it; I’m blasting him for lying about it under oath.)

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

Iranians trying to detonate dirty bomb in DC: CNN

10 hours ago

United Airlines bricked

11 hours ago

Widespread bank account access outages reported

15 hours ago

Semi-embalmed corpse can’t even get his confused lies straight

19 hours ago

True ruler of CBS puts Bari Weiss on notice

19 hours ago

Eric Trump-backed killer robot startup founder’s embezzlement raises questions over Trump Admin’s ability to unleash AI uprising

2 days ago

Sean Duffy refuses to apologize for Pete Buttigieg’s atrocities

2 days ago

Flight safety expert weighs in on air traffic modernization efforts

2 days ago

“They thought the ad was in poor taste, but…”

2 days ago

Buttigiegment Day

3 days ago

Team Orange pushes back Medicaid work requirements

3 days ago

Regime allowed illegal Chinese vapes imported to benefit crony

3 days ago

Markwayne turns all woke speech-police on reporter

3 days ago

FAA orders nationwide ground halt

3 days ago

“Front Row Joe” says he voted for Amy Acton and Sherrod Brown

4 days ago

Jaydee leaning toward sitting out 2028: CNN

4 days ago

Scott Bessent throws Howard Nutlick to the wolves

4 days ago

Final weeks before election saw massive pro-Dem sandbagging

4 days ago

An economy depending on one guy to not fuck around is…

4 days ago

Todd not sure how to answer question on nonexistent voter fraud

5 days ago

Trump appoints Tim Apple to run Nvidia

5 days ago

Nvidia CEO resigns

5 days ago

Caravan scam continues apace

5 days ago

CNN calls Mississippi for Scott Colom

5 days ago

Ilhan Omar’s bodyguard indicted to try to get him to “flip”: NYT

6 days ago

Insufferable shithead MAGA Congressman Greg Murphy concedes

6 days ago

“We did do a very poor job”

6 days ago

Regime sends letter warning Garcia of “criminal consequences”

6 days ago

Mary Peltola’s vote total now larger than both Dan Sullivans

6 days ago

Hegseth COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY EXONERATED

6 days ago

Tom Emmer promises Dems will regret winning

6 days ago

Jim Jordan wins House GOP leadership, lol

7 days ago

“Many Democrat lawmakers are going to find themselves under indictment and fighting conviction… Watch”: Roger Stone to Axios

7 days ago

Bidenflation increases 0.4 percent in October, beating expectations

7 days ago

WATCH LIVE: Petey Pee Pants calls impeachment gay and soy

7 days ago

Orange Baby still demanding Dan Sullivan be declared winner

7 days ago

Orange God Emperor holds impromptu press briefing: Watch live

1 week ago

“Voters made the wrong choice”

1 week ago

Massie intros Hegseth impeachment articles

1 week ago

Nvidia CEO hired top sex scandal specialist PR firm a year ago

1 week ago

There it is: Trump “Stop the Steal 2026” edition

1 week ago

Russell Brand gets 10.5 years in the joint following rape conviction

1 week ago

Jaydee “blamed the Jews for losing the election”: Randy Fine

1 week ago

Jensen Huang in better shape with Trump than JD Vance

1 week ago

Katie Miller cancels podcast

1 week ago

Todd says he’s investigating Dem “threats”: Sunday Live updates

1 week ago

Mentally ill senior having fun Saturday shitposting on internet

1 week ago

Will Dems even need to nuke the filibuster in 2029?

1 week ago

Top Trump crony Huang targeted by sexy Chicom intel agent

1 week ago

WATCH LIVE: Trump complains about losing to NASA

1 week ago

x
x
x
x
x
x