Categories
Uncategorized

Private donor paying for South Dakota National Guard troops to be sent to Texas border raises serious ethical questions

At the bequest of Willis Johnson, a Tennessee billionaire and the deep pockets financing many conservative causes, South Dakota Republican Governor Kristi Noem dispatched 50 members of the state’s National Guard to the Texas border following a disaster announcement by Texas Republican Governor Greg Abbott.

But as the New York Times reports, the privately-funded mission of the South Dakota National Guard–with dollars from Johnson (who, it should be noted, doesn’t even live in South Dakota) and orders from Noem–raises a plethora of legal, ethical and political questions.

The move smacks of Noem turning the state’s Guard into a mercenary force, available for assignments to the highest bidder.  Is the Guard the militia of the People of South Dakota, paid for by citizens of not just South Dakota but all of the US?  Or is it a private security firm that can be deployed at the whim of the governor to make a political statement?

And who will be responsible for any injury or fatality of a South Dakota Guardsman who is sent to Texas at the request of a Tennessee billionaire?  Would the member of the Guard be eligible for benefits?  Should the family be granted military survivor benefits for a private foray inspired by political ambition?

More than a century ago, the federal government set up a funding mechanism for the National Guard after citizens voiced concern that the Guard was being used as strikebreakers during work stoppages at mines.  The mining company would frequently send money to political cronies to have the Guard come to a site and break strikers.  The Militia Act of 1903–also known as the Dick Act of 1903–effectively ended this practice by putting Guard funding under federal auspices.

For her part, Noem sees no issue with having a billionaire hire members of the US military.  She can claim that she’s helping protect the US border without spending a taxpayer dime.  She gets national exposure for an expected upcoming presidential run.  And she gets to do all this while courting the support of an important GOP fundraiser.

Others, however, aren’t so sure.  “I don’t have a clue if it’s legal,” said Roger Tellinghuisen, a Republican who served as South Dakota attorney general. “It’s a question in my own mind.”

“There are instances in South Dakota where we have private funding of government activities, but you see it more commonly in construction projections than in operations,” said Neil Fulton, who served as chief of staff to former Gov. Mike Rounds, a Republican, and is now the dean of the University of South Dakota School of Law.

Scholars of South Dakota government operations–and there are apparently at least one of them–say that there’s no mechanism in state law to allow for a private funder to provide money to the state coffers to finance a National Guard deployment.

And there are some who see it as outright illegal.  “It’s basically money laundering, and it’s turning the state National Guard into a mercenary force,” said Rachel VanLandingham, a former Air Force lawyer who is a professor at Southwestern Law School in Los Angeles. “She’s using troops there that are a resource and have been paid for by taxpayers that are being used for a political show by a high-powered donor because the governor thought it was a good idea.”

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

They lowered gas prices after the “election”: President

5 hours ago

“We still gotta live our life at the same time”

11 hours ago

NSA’s internal network crashes

12 hours ago

Markwayne flew to Texas-LSU game while FAA chaos still raged

15 hours ago

WATCH LIVE: Embarrassment takes stage in Philippines

17 hours ago

Iranians trying to detonate dirty bomb in DC: CNN

1 day ago

United Airlines bricked

1 day ago

Widespread bank account access outages reported

1 day ago

Semi-embalmed corpse can’t even get his confused lies straight

2 days ago

True ruler of CBS puts Bari Weiss on notice

2 days ago

Eric Trump-backed killer robot startup founder’s embezzlement raises questions over Trump Admin’s ability to unleash AI uprising

2 days ago

Sean Duffy refuses to apologize for Pete Buttigieg’s atrocities

3 days ago

Flight safety expert weighs in on air traffic modernization efforts

3 days ago

“They thought the ad was in poor taste, but…”

3 days ago

Buttigiegment Day

3 days ago

Team Orange pushes back Medicaid work requirements

3 days ago

Regime allowed illegal Chinese vapes imported to benefit crony

4 days ago

Markwayne turns all woke speech-police on reporter

4 days ago

FAA orders nationwide ground halt

4 days ago

“Front Row Joe” says he voted for Amy Acton and Sherrod Brown

4 days ago

Jaydee leaning toward sitting out 2028: CNN

5 days ago

Scott Bessent throws Howard Nutlick to the wolves

5 days ago

Final weeks before election saw massive pro-Dem sandbagging

5 days ago

An economy depending on one guy to not fuck around is…

5 days ago

Todd not sure how to answer question on nonexistent voter fraud

5 days ago

Trump appoints Tim Apple to run Nvidia

5 days ago

Nvidia CEO resigns

6 days ago

Caravan scam continues apace

6 days ago

CNN calls Mississippi for Scott Colom

6 days ago

Ilhan Omar’s bodyguard indicted to try to get him to “flip”: NYT

6 days ago

Insufferable shithead MAGA Congressman Greg Murphy concedes

6 days ago

“We did do a very poor job”

7 days ago

Regime sends letter warning Garcia of “criminal consequences”

7 days ago

Mary Peltola’s vote total now larger than both Dan Sullivans

7 days ago

Hegseth COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY EXONERATED

1 week ago

Tom Emmer promises Dems will regret winning

1 week ago

Jim Jordan wins House GOP leadership, lol

1 week ago

“Many Democrat lawmakers are going to find themselves under indictment and fighting conviction… Watch”: Roger Stone to Axios

1 week ago

Bidenflation increases 0.4 percent in October, beating expectations

1 week ago

WATCH LIVE: Petey Pee Pants calls impeachment gay and soy

1 week ago

Orange Baby still demanding Dan Sullivan be declared winner

1 week ago

Orange God Emperor holds impromptu press briefing: Watch live

1 week ago

“Voters made the wrong choice”

1 week ago

Massie intros Hegseth impeachment articles

1 week ago

Nvidia CEO hired top sex scandal specialist PR firm a year ago

1 week ago

There it is: Trump “Stop the Steal 2026” edition

1 week ago

Russell Brand gets 10.5 years in the joint following rape conviction

1 week ago

Jaydee “blamed the Jews for losing the election”: Randy Fine

1 week ago

Jensen Huang in better shape with Trump than JD Vance

1 week ago

Katie Miller cancels podcast

1 week ago

x
x
x
x
x
x