Categories
Uncategorized

Trump’s No Good Very Bad Legal Day takes down surprising not-so-innocent victim in fray: Judge Aileen Cannon’s career

We can all agree that there was much schadenfreude on this site today.  From watching New York Attorney General Leticia James recite scam after scam after scam while announcing a quarter billion dollar (minimum!) civil suit against Donald Trump to the stay issued by the 11th Circuit upholding national security concerns to E. Jean Carroll announcing she’s filing a civil suit against Trump for a 1990s rape (alleged), today was a very, very bad day from the legal perspective for Donald Trump.  Arrows were flying at him from every direction.

Save some of the schadenfreude for poor Aileen Cannon, the staff attorney at a federal prosecutor’s office turned federal judge with a lifetime appointment.  Don’t get me wrong:  I don’t want you to feel sorry for her.  I truly want you to savor the fact that the decision means that every future session she has on the bench will be hell for her.

The decision issued by the 11th Circuit didn’t just overrule her widely-mocked opinion, it eviscerated her legal reasoning.  Not one of the points Cannon outlined in her decision to deny the stay was recognized as a rational legal point by the three judges–including two appointed by Donald Trump–who heard the Justice Department’s appeal.

The panel repeatedly noted–in polite legalese–that Cannon’s decisions made no sense.  The most telling was subtly tucked into page 17 of the decision, where the panel called out Cannon basically yadda yadda yadda-ing around the Richey factors she cited to hear and support the motion by Trump’s lawyers to take extraordinary measures to protect Trump.

In discussing the first factor outlined in Richey v. Smith for granting the additional measures–that is, that prosecutors have shown “callous disregard” for the rights and privacy of the target of a search–Cannon acknowledged in her decision that neither she nor Trump’s attorneys could identify any such action:

With respect to the first factor, the Court agrees with the Government that, at least based on the record to date, there has not been a compelling showing of callous disregard for Plaintiff’s constitutional rights.

How did the 11th’s panel respond to this?  Directly, to say the least, citing the necessity for that component to uphold her decision:

The absence of this “indispensab[le]” factor in the Richey analysis is reason enough to conclude that the district court abused its discretion in exercising equitable jurisdiction here.  But for the sake of completeness, we consider the remaining factors.

And, boy, did they.  As they examined, and summarily dismissed, each factor of Cannon’s decision, they peppered their opinion with very direct admonishments:  statements like “We agree [with the Government]” and “We are not persuaded” were woven throughout the decision.

An important statement by the 11th Circuit panel was how forcefully it stood by the classification of the documents, a matter Cannon questioned the veracity of, though it was asserted by the Department of Justice.  Cannon expressed doubts about sworn statements by government attorneys claiming the documents were still classified; the panel was having none of it, questioning why a former president would have need of classified (or previously classified) information:

In any event, at least for these purposes, the declassification argument is a red herring because declassifying an official document would not change its content or render it personal. So even if we assumed that Plaintiff did declassify some or all of the documents, that would not explain why he has a personal interest in them.

Frequently in the ruling, the panel questioned how Cannon came to her decisions, noting that plain non-contested evidence pointed to the exact opposite conclusions to which Cannon arrived.

So Trump is going to ruin another person’s reputation, which happens to people who give him their allegiance.  Thankfully, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals–with two Trump nominees–has temporarily put a stop to dispensing justice for political favor.

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

Trump removes $3 million lawyer from Mar-a-Lago case

1 hour ago

Complete douchebag Capitol rioter convicted, faces 25 years

2 hours ago

At induction center, Russia conscripts told to fend for themselves

3 hours ago

Consumer confidence rigged in September

3 hours ago

DeSantis privately talking a lot of shit about Trump: report

4 hours ago

“Libertarian” sues Biden Admin over student debt forgiveness

4 hours ago

Walker campaign lists MAGA rioter, fake elector as local “captains”

5 hours ago

Facebook kills off massive Russian propaganda network

5 hours ago

Military-aged Russian men pour out of country

6 hours ago

Secret Service confiscated 24 agents’ phones in Capitol riot probe

7 hours ago

Jury selection begins Tuesday in Oath Keepers leaders’ trial

7 hours ago

Four plead guilty in 2018 North Carolina GOP election scam

10 hours ago

Ken Paxton fled his home to avoid being served with subpoena

14 hours ago

Walker wants you to know he’s got some Native American friends and they’re perfectly okay with Atlanta mascot, so there

15 hours ago

Man shot in face trying to steal guns from Chicago SWAT facility

16 hours ago

This is a thing in Florida… It is a thing in Florida, right? They do this?

17 hours ago

Get outside! Look up! Jupiter will be brightest it’s been in 59 years

17 hours ago

Welcome to Overemoting Theatre starring Tucker Carlson

17 hours ago

Feds say Navarro used private email account for official business

18 hours ago

Manufacturing jobs increase from pre-pandemic levels

18 hours ago

McConnell whipping Republican Senate votes to block Manchin’s energy permitting bill just to be a dick

18 hours ago

Watch live as NASA attacks innocent asteroid

19 hours ago

Dozens show up to Mastriano rally

21 hours ago

BREAKING: SMARTMATIC UNDER FEDERAL INVESTIGATION

22 hours ago

Pollution fan whines about criticism of World Bank president who refused to acknowledge economic impact of climate change

22 hours ago

It’s official: Cuba has more human rights than Red States

22 hours ago

MAGA Arizona “election integrity” unit complete failure

23 hours ago

Student debt cancellation relatively cheap: CBO

24 hours ago

Kremlin grants Edward Snowden Russian citizenship. He’s now eligible for conscription into Russian military to fight in Ukraine

1 day ago

Kurdish women in Syria stage protests in solidarity with Iranians

1 day ago

Wisconsin’s Vos tries to block January 6th committee subpoena

1 day ago

With 87% vaccination rate, Canada lifts some Covid restrictions

1 day ago

Capitol rioter who Trump White House called identified by CNN

1 day ago

School shooting in Russia leaves 13 dead, 21 wounded

1 day ago

Mark Meadows texted hardcore MAGA conspiracy freak Phil Waldron in late December 2020 about seizing voting machines

1 day ago

Zelenskyy confirms Ukraine received US surface-to-air system

2 days ago

McCarthy vows to enforce accountability regardless of Party in promise no one actually believes he’ll keep

2 days ago

Right wing hell witch probably next Italian leader: Exit polls

2 days ago

Unpermitted car rally in Wildwood, NJ leaves 2 dead

2 days ago

Texas 12-year-old girl shoots father, turns gun on herself in murder pact with friend to annihilate families

2 days ago

Anti-conscription protests continue across Russia

2 days ago

Utah’s Mike Lee lies when citing “federal overreach” as he chooses to defend harassment of LGBTQ people, assault on elderly man

2 days ago

North Korea launches missile in sign of impotent rage at upcoming visit to South by VP Harris, scheduled military exercise

2 days ago

Judge threatens Rudy with jail in divorce lawsuit

2 days ago

DeSantis declared state of emergency for Florida, but only because of an approaching hurricane, not in general as he should

2 days ago

Elijah McClain died of ketamine overdose administered by paramedics after police restrained him, autopsy finds

3 days ago

Watch your posture: how you sit, stand determines how quickly oral medications are absorbed into your system, study finds

3 days ago

Georgia orders replacement of election machines accessed illegally by Trump conspiracy-minded elections official

3 days ago

NASA Artemis launch scrapped again

3 days ago

Security at Trump rally tried to prevent QAnon gesture

3 days ago

x
x
x
x
x
x