Categories
Uncategorized

Pennsylvania Republican’s grad school research into Sgt. York questioned, may lead to revocation of his Ph.D.

Rising Pennsylvania Republican firebrand Doug Mastriano was awarded a Ph.D. for a his research into location in France of the legendary battle where Sgt. Alvin York nearly single-handedly captured 132 German soldiers during World War I.

It turns all his conclusions are wrong, according to a report by the Associated Press.  He missed the mark by a half mile.

Still, Pennsylvania state senator Mastriano refuses to accept the findings of dozens of historians, researchers and archeologists, claiming that there’s nothing incorrect about their findings and he’s completely right–even though researchers have found relics from York’s unit at the competing location.

Elected to his first term in the state senate riding the wave of Trumpism in 2019, Mastriano has made a habit of dismissing facts.  He was a major force in pushing the Pennsylvania Senate to dismiss the results of the 2020 presidential election, and he spoke at Trump’s January 6th “Stop the Steal” rally claiming that there was widespread voter fraud.  Reportedly, he’s considering a run for governor in 2022.

The unraveling of Mastriano’s thesis started when people began to review his cited sources.  The passages he cited, for both important facts and detritus, frequently didn’t have anything to do with what he claimed.  For example, a source in York’s autobiography (itself with a questionable pedigree) that Mastriano cites as evidence that York was offered $20,000 weekly to appear in a traveling revue actually has York talking about his love of hunting.

Mastriano’s headline claim in his 2009 thesis–that he had definitively found the spot near the village of Chatel-Chehery, France where York undertook his heroic mission–led to praise and a book deal.  It also prompted him to raise money for a 2-mile historic walk directing history buffs to the spot of York’s mission.

Mastriano claimed he found shell casings that he, somehow, identified as York’s.  He even claimed that he found a photo in the US Army Signal Corps archives that showed York escorting his newly-captured German prisoners.

There were many problems with these claims.  First off, the photo was labeled by the photographer as being taken 12 days before York’s actions.  Mastriano claims that the caption is simply wrong:  the photo shows three officers York is known to have captured; a mustached man is obviously York, and the Army says no actions took place 12 days before York’s mission that would have resulted in so many prisoners.

In fact, other photographs of the German officers shows little resemblance to the men in the photo; the mustachioed man in the photo could be anyone; and the Army does, in fact, show hundreds of German prisoners captured 12 days before York captured 132 men.

The biggest blow to Mastriano’s claim is the discovery more than ten years ago of material emblazoned with the insignia of York’s unit, as well as a trove of abandoned German material and weapons–as if they were abandoned after surrendering–a half mile away.

Based on this information and the findings that scores of Mastriano’s citations were false, University of Oklahoma history graduate student James Gregory has filed an appeal to the University of New Brunswick, who awarded Mastriano his Ph.D., and the University of Kentucky Press, who published his book, calling for a review of the thesis.  That could lead the University of New Brunswick to revoke Mastriano’s degree due to it being based false evidence of faulty research.

Mastriano, being a Trumplican, refuses to believe the evidence presented to him.  He insists he is right and everyone else is wrong, as if it’s a conspiracy to discredit him.

Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019

Blurry Oregon ballot barcodes unreadable by scanner, delaying tally of last week’s primary votes

1 hour ago

RINO cuck soyboy Rick Scott agrees Biden duly elected President

2 hours ago

Plane carrying imported baby formula lands in Indiana

2 hours ago

Jif peanut butter recalled due to salmonella contamination

3 hours ago

God punishes Gaylord

3 hours ago

Kansas moved away from border, state’s GOP Senator believes

4 hours ago

CPAC Hungary features speech by hardcore anti-semite

5 hours ago

MAGA Land not pleased to reap the whirlwind

6 hours ago

QAnon con emcee gets lyrics to National Anthem wrong

7 hours ago

Don Jr’s hunting guide faces five years for rigging 2018 bear hunt

19 hours ago

Petulant Russia cuts off gas to Finland after NATO application

21 hours ago

Walker’s connection to veterans group he claimed to have founded another in series of exaggerations he’s made to bolster resume

21 hours ago

Like everything else, Trump making abortion overturn about himself, telling minions it’ll hurt his chances in 2024: report

1 day ago

Six percent of Western Texas county’s total population, county executive judge included, arrested for cattle rustling

1 day ago

Aussie center-left Labor party crush ruling right wing party

1 day ago

RonAnon’s communications director quits

1 day ago

Random thoughts Friday, Volume LXX

2 days ago

Thanks, CBS

2 days ago

MAGA Michigan candidate wants ban on all contraception

2 days ago

HUGE! Campaign manager testifies Hillary PERSONALLY APPROVED the leak of the TRUMP-RUSSIA BANK connection!

2 days ago

Eastman tries to shield hand-written Trump notes from falling into hands of House January 6th investigators

2 days ago

Republican advocacy group that targeted Cawthorn in primary adjusts its sights to take down Boebert

2 days ago

Team Oz and Team McCormick both hire Trump 2020 lawyers

2 days ago

Conservative TikTok poster believes she’s the first person to figure out how to avoid paying federal income tax (She hasn’t)

2 days ago

Republican Virginia state lawmaker Tim Anderson sues Barnes and Noble to force them to stop selling LGBT-themed books to kids

2 days ago

Stygian hag Ginni Thomas emailed Arizona lawmakers to get them to overturn election and send fake Trump slate to electoral college

2 days ago

Clickbait tweet omits actual outcome

2 days ago

Americans exporting gun violence to Canada, study shows

2 days ago

The Devil’s not going back down to Georgia… just yet

2 days ago

US intel pretty sure Putin doesn’t actually care what Russians think

2 days ago

High school dropout happier to complain than actually help

2 days ago

Biden authorizes $100 million in military aid to Ukraine

3 days ago

That’s all good, but Joe won’t have a photo op with Kim, so….

3 days ago

Florida man forges pardon from Trump to get out of fraud charges

3 days ago

Montana GOP House candidate Zinke actually California resident

3 days ago

Judge throws out Lindell “frivolous” defamation lawsuits against Smartmatic, Dominion Voting Systems

3 days ago

Socialist Alaska OK’s $3,200 payout to residents from confiscation of corporate profits

3 days ago

Cawthorn trying desperately to maintain relevance

3 days ago

SpaceX paid woman $250K after Musk exposed himself to her

3 days ago

Forced birther claims Washington DC runs on fetus power

3 days ago

January 6th House investigators believe Georgia Republican gave tours of Capitol day before domestic terrorist attack… but it ain’t her

3 days ago

Topless breastfeeding supermom saves pet goose from eagle

3 days ago

Trump reportedly suggested jailing, executing Michigan Secretary of State for not overturning 2020 election results to give him win

3 days ago

“We understand that the use of imagery depicting Mr Soros as a puppet-master at our state convention raised concerns, buuut…”

3 days ago

Every Republican House member votes against bill authorizing FTC to investigate price gouging by oil companies

3 days ago

Matt Schlapp states abortion ban is conservative counteraction to “Great Replacement Theory” to bolster Real ‘Murican voter rolls

3 days ago

So many incel MAGA boys are heartbroken as the woman they secretly lust over didn’t choose them

3 days ago

Senate passes $40 billion in aid to Ukrane

3 days ago

Ch00Ch00 News is run by low-T soyboys

3 days ago

Oklahoma legislature passes ban on abortion at fertilization

3 days ago

x
x
x
x
x
x